Showing posts with label green lantern. Show all posts
Showing posts with label green lantern. Show all posts

Friday, May 24, 2013

Off The Top Of My Head....



I opened up my blog for the first time in several months without a specific intent of what I was going to be writing about.  I mean I have spent the last 7 or so blogs putting my fan-fic Jason Todd stories out there and hadn't really addressed anything else.  So when I decided today was the day to put a new blog out there, I realized I didn't have the slightest idea WHAT I wanted to talk about....



There's Iron Man 3...which I enjoyed, thought it tried to hard for laughs at times, still not sure how I feel about The Mandarin twist, was surprised the 9pm premiere audience I was a part of didn't pop for the spots one would expect (like Pepper's big moment), and I thought the post-credits scene was cute...they don't always have to tease you for the next big movie and I don't see how a Thor 2 one would have worked here anyway.



We've got Man of Steel on tap in June and with each new trailer I find my excitement growing. The movie looks amazing and the "Can't I just keep pretending I'm your son? You ARE my son." exchange cinched it for me.  This is my movie of the year and June 14th can't come fast enough but since I now work on Thursday nights there is no midnight (or 7pm Walmart screening) in my future for any upcoming movies.  One thing I wanted to touch on about this movie though, and it's something inspired in my brain by a conversation with a friend yesterday as well as reading this from Brett White on CBR earlier today, is the idea of DARK AND GRITTY!!!

I was asked if I thought Man of Steel would be just that and it led me on a tangent about how there is no reason for that to exist in the world of Clark Kent.  Yes the movie is being put out there by Zach Snyder who helped define those words in movies like 300 & Watchmen (just as much as Nolan did in his Bat-Trilogy) but it doesn't play in the world of Supes.  As White said in his piece, Superman represents hope and unity and all the good things in a world too often filled with negativity and with the bad.  Yes his birth planet was blown up but he was raised by two loving parents in a safe environment, brought up with strong values, grew up believing in the best of humanity, and strives to be that everyday.  This quote IS the perfect summary: "You will give the people of Earth an ideal to strive towards. They'll race behind you. They will stumble. They will fall. But in time, they will join you in the sun."

That's what Supes is about and while I, like White, have generally shied away from Superman, there are those tales that capture it perfectly. I have read both Birthright and All-Star and they are amazing books...just takes the right author to make me care.  Obviously Clark is going to have some issues, "surprise you're an alien" would be hard news to take no matter how well you were raised, but I don't want to see a brooding Bruce Wayne clone hiding inside Clark when he's all bearded and looks to be in full-on drifter mode. I want that to be a man learning about a world beyond Smallville and doing what he can to help where he can.  It's hopefully the journey of a man finding out he's a hero, not of a man running away from who he is...

Also, I think I would put the same notion on Captain America as well...a "dark and gritty" Cap is not for me, it worked for Winter Soldier because of the life Bucky had endured but not for Steve Rogers.  Maybe it's no coincidence that one of the Superman stories & the Steve Rogers Captain America stories I dig the most are written by Mark Waid...



So what shocks me, especially coming as a sequel (of sorts) to two of the most despised comic books movies, is that I am totally intrigued by The Wolverine!  At first it was thrown out there as a sequel to X-Men Origins: Wolverine, then it evolved into a sequel to X-Men: The Last Stand, but the movie still maintains it is based on the amazing Chris Claremont/Frank Miller Wolverine mini-series from 1982 (on the must-read list for any X-Fan out there, it's where the whole "best at what I do" catchphrase started after all).  

Based on the experience of Origins (a movie I wanted to like but just can't) and The Last Stand (a movie I enjoy but see why others don't), I wasn't very sure about this movie ever happening in any form and once it was announced that it was, suffice to say my guard was up.  When Darren Aronofsky was briefly attached I was certainly intrigued by how he would present a super hero movie but my interest was about as fleeting as his I suppose.  Having no clue who James Mangold was my desire for this movie to exist was...well...not nonexistent...but damn close.  As a matter of fact it is only just now as I am writing this that I bothered to look at his IMDB to see that he directed two movies I enjoy in Walk The Line & Identity...nice!

Anywho, it wasn't until I started seeing the trailers that my interest was piqued and, just as with Man of Steel, it took multiple variations before it completely captured my attention.  Now, after seeing the ninja fighting, the giant (robot?) Silver Samurai, Yukio, Viper, and the Famke Janssen spot...I am there.  The Jean Grey moment in the trailer was similar to the acknowledgment from Tony in Iron Man 3 that what happened in NYC had affected him.  For better or worse, the fact that X3 is being recognized and that the events of that movie will have repercussions on The Wolverine makes me a happy continuity nerd!  Plus I have a very strong desire to see how, or if, this movie will play into the next piece of film business that has my attention...




 X-Men: Days of Future Past!  I am scared, excited, nervous, happy, anxious, etcetera etcetera for this one.  It sounds so ambitious and loaded with every damn X-Character under the sun, bringing back Shawn Ashmore and Anna Paquin and Patrick Stewart and Ian McKellen as well as First Class cast members and, of course, Hugh Jackman.  Promises of making sense out of the continuity chaos that is the cinematic X-Verse have me salivating at the prospects of how this could be accomplished.  Will it be like JJ Abrams Star Trek where it plays as a prequel, sequel, and reboot all at the same time?  How will the past & future interact? Time travel? Alternate realities?  How will those tropes of comic book fantasy work in cinema?  I cannot wait to see how it all plays out!  First Class Xavier meet Trilogy Xavier!




My wandering mind just steered back to Iron Man 3, more specifically Robert Downey Jr's future in the Marvel movie-verse.  I think it is impossible to argue that he is the foundation upon which the current Avengers movie franchise was built...if it wasn't for the success of the original Iron Man and how amazing the guy was in the role of Tony Stark, it is extremely safe to say we wouldn't have gotten to the point where Marvel is willing to make the ballsy play of releasing a Guardians of the Galaxy movie.  Hell, we would never have gotten to ONE Avengers movie for that matter...

So while I am dumbfounded by the dollar figures attached to both RDJ and Joss Whedon ($50 million for Downey in Avengers, $100 million contract for Whedon), based on how much money their movies have made for the company, it is hard to argue they aren't worth the price tag.  It's just telling of our society that while we pay entertainers that much, for the majority of us who keep the gears turning on a daily basis those numbers are imaginary and unreachable.  GET OFF THE SOAPBOX!!!

I don't bring this up to talk about that disparity though, I bring it up because of the disparity within the Avengers franchise when it comes to pay scale.  I can understand paying the top draw the top money (to use a wrestling comparison Ricky Steamboat would never have made Hulk Hogan money) but, if the numbers are legit, to pay some of the cast $200,000 while Downey & Whedon made that much...it's insulting.  So when I read that Downey is actually standing up for his fellow castmates and this drastic discrepancy, I want to applaud the man.  Take Scarlet Johansson for one...they obviously feel she is very important, after all she has appeared in two of the Phase One movies (Iron Man 2, Avengers) and is filming Captain America: Winter Soldier.  Aside from Samuel L. Jackson's Nick Fury and Clark Gregg's Agent Coulson (HIS NAME WAS PHIL!), she has been the most high-profile character to not have her own movie.  I know Jeremy Renner's Hawkeye was also in two of the Phase One movies, but he was barely a factor in Thor...nowhere near as important as Black Widow was to Iron Man 2 or, now that I think about it, Coulson to the whole franchise.

If she is one of the $200K crew, I wouldn't blame her for wanting to balance the scales and get more black in her ledger (that was awful).  Same goes for Chris Evans and Chris Hemsworth who are THE LEAD ACTORS in their own franchise...their movies may not bank as much as Iron Man but still, they are the face of the character.

It will be interesting to see if Marvel recasts these parts for Avengers 2 or if they balance the pay scales out to try and keep the band together.  Also can't help but wonder where Mark Ruffalo falls in all of this...he's awesome as Bruce Banner but he will, much like Hawkeye and Black Widow, probably never see his own movie.



Comic books....or at least one of them, the much anticipated and much delayed Age of Ultron event! This damn thing was first teased over two years ago in Avengers (Vol. 4) #12.1, then again during the 2012 Free Comic Comic Book day Age of Ultron #0.1 issue that reprinted the Avengers story, and here we are in 2013 and it is FINALLY starting, and almost over due to a bi-weekly print schedule, presumably to make way for Infinity this summer.

Honestly I should know better by now to expect much out of Bendis written event books after Secret Invasion and Siege.

The former had that snail's pacing with everything of interest to me (i.e. back story) happening in the Avengers tie-in books Bendis was writing.  Sure SI had some cool moments but, in the end & in the long run, none of the Skrull reveals mattered and it ended up feeling like 8 issues of set-up for Dark Reign.

The latter, well, I just didn't care...I loved Norman Osborn's role during Dark Reign and spent the entire time waiting for that Goblin reveal but when it happened, it just fell flat.  The story being cut down to four issues I took as Marvel realizing SI was TOO LONG but even at that shorter length Siege felt long to me.

So now we have AoU, obviously a play on the Age of Apocalypse name, and it feels like this just a story being ran through as quickly as possible because it was promised to us two years ago.  It reads dated too because of that...particularly in the way Bendis writes Spider-Man.  Now it has been insisted by Marvel that the AoU Spidey IS the Superior Spidey version but anyone who reads that book can see that either (A) Bendis has NO idea how to write Octo-Spidey or (B) He wrote this two years ago before Superior Spidey was a thought and just left it as Peter.  Superior Spidey has a very distinctive way of talking that screams "THIS ISN'T PETER", his body language screams "I'M NOT PETER", and yet everything about AoU Spidey reads like Peter.  It drives me nuts....

That aside, the pacing is glacial...the heroes stood around talking for four issues like it was an on-going series...and I just find it hard to get behind an alternate reality story of this nature.  When AoA happened you knew the books would eventually get back to reality BUT the entire X-Men line changed to reflect the death of Xavier.  I know that's not something possible to do in this more integrated Marvel U (back then the X-Men played all by themselves 99.9% of the time) but, maybe in part due to the fact that the next event was being solicited before this one even got started, AoU comes across like an afterthought in every way.  It would have been ballsy but imagine if Marvel had changed the ENTIRE landscape for the duration of this book?  That tells the readers something serious is going on here...and if you plan it in advance, much like the transition into AoA world, a writer can segue their story into it as much as possible then pick up the pieces when reality returns to normal.

Yet, like the glutton for punishment I am, I am continuing to read the series...it's got nice art and some cool moments but, like a review I read said...maybe on CBR...this is a story that could have played out over a couple issues of Exiles or the recently canned Extreme X-Men book.


Everything before this was written Thursday, everything from this point on was written Friday.  It will make sense why I am pointing that out shortly...

So I just finished reading Green Lantern #20, the final issue of Geoff Johns' nearly ten year running manning the Hal Jordan ship and redefining the landscape of the GL-Verse.  I have written about this before...

- Green Lantern & The New 52...10/15/12
- Rebirth 7/1/11
- Sinestro Corps Part 2 6/12/11
- Sinestro Corps Part 1 6/6/11
- Blackest Night 5/16/11

...but not in any detail since the New 52 began.  To be honest about it, I have not been greatly engrossed in anything going on in the GL books since Blackest Night ended.  I was not a fan of the Brightest Day/War of the Green Lanterns saga that wrapped up the old DCU and, aside from enjoying the interaction between Hal & Sinestro, I haven't been very engrossed by the New 52 stories.  I don't care about Baz at all yet, the Wrath of the First Lantern story was boring as hell to me with essentially every chapter just repeating the same "false reality inflicted on a lead character" angle.  The only exception, and the brightest spot of the arc, has been the Hal & Sinestro in the Dead Zone pages of which they were not a great deal. Suffice to say that I couldn't wait for this arc to end even though it meant Johns leaving the book.

All that being said, I have to say that GL #20 was an amazing send-off for Geoff, Doug Mahnke, and everyone else who helped build the GL-Verse into the behemoth it has become since Rebirth.  Yes we have seen the "rewrite reality" schtick done a million times over in comic books but in this issue, for the first time in this arc, it really feels like Volthoom's purpose is secondary to the real story: the story of Hal & Sinestro.  Volthoom is a prop, his mission is background noise, the endless supply of Lanterns from every color are meaningless in this larger story...this is ultimately about Hal, Sinestro, and their enduring friendship despite everything that has happened over the years.  Hal still wants to believe Sinestro is a good man, he will not give up on him, and Sinestro actually does demonstrate he still has that heart.  Hell I think it's safe to say that Sinestro is the MOST emotional of all these beings floating around space.

Add in all the quotes from various creators, friends, and family reflecting on Johns' run as well as Geoff's own farewell to the GL-Verse, and you have quite a complete package for a final issue.  It even answers some of the "what's still continuity?" questions that linger from the old DCU into the New 52!

So despite my general lack of interest in the last year and a half of Green Lantern, I am quite sad to see such an epic run come to an end. Let me say though that it is not a matter of the book being bad, well except for maybe the majority of Wrath of the First Lantern, it just that it is hard to match the levels of awesomeness achieved with Blackest Night, Sinestro Corps War, Rebirth, and all the other stories that have built to this finale.

It changed the face of DC Comics, it brought Hal Jordan, a character I was only tangentially familiar with from Reign of the Supermen, into my wheel house and made me love him, and it used the building blocks of what came before to create a new and very deep mythos around the GLC. 


This is the reason I felt it necessary to point out that I'm writing this part on Friday, hence the reason I didn't just lump it in with the Days of Future Past block.

So Quicksilver, who Joss Whedon had recently announced would be be part of Avengers 2 alongside Scarlet Witch, is now also going to be part of the X-Men: Days of Future Past cast! WTF?!?!

The internet kind of had a meltdown for a minute, thinking we might suddenly start seeing the two distinct movie franchises from two separate studios share a universe or something, but the reality of that ever happening is...none.  Not even slim to none...just the none.

It makes me curious why this is happening...is it a move out of spite? A challenge? Doing it because they can?  It also makes me wonder just what other characters could fall into this same murky water of being available to both movie franchises.  Does it depend on which comic book they first appeared in or which comic they appeared in most frequently?  Not even getting into the current A+X world Marvel Comics lives in, you've got characters like Beast and Carol Danvers who have been involved with both teams for decades, or even Wolverine & Spider-Man who have been part of the Avengers for nearly a decade.  What is it that determines movie rights exactly?  Could the Fantastic Four, three of whom have been Avengers in the past, be used?  I am more intrigued by HOW this works than anything else...


Trinity War is almost here and do I care? I think the answer is a lifeless grunt.  Not quite as drawn out as the delay between AoU's tease and the actual publication, this mega-event for the New 52 was first teased in the 2012 FCBD book from DC.  This isn't something unusual for Geoff Johns by the way as he did exactly that for Sinestro Corps War (teased in the final issue of Rebirth I think) and Blackest Night (teased in the last part of Sinestro Corps War) BUT I felt like those stories were built towards in the gaps.

I'm not sure if Trinity has actually been built towards...maybe that's the kind of thing where the pieces will fall into place when I get to read it.  Right now it it just feels like I am being TOLD this is important instead of being SHOWN it's important. I read JL, JLA, and JLD and I in no way feel like these books are headed for some big collision in just two months time...and building it around a big murder mystery premise is doing nothing for me.  Maybe I'm just being cynical comic book guy here but let's see, Johns just introduced three new JL members in The Atom, Element Woman, and Firestorm (the only one who had his own book).  Well is it a safe bet to say either Atom or Element Woman are dying?  Batman, Superman, Wonder Woman, Aquaman, and Flash all have their own book, Cyborg's involvement (despite not adding up to much of anything for most of the series) was pushed as a big deal, and Green Lantern Jordan technically quit.  So again...safe bet on one of the newbies getting killed.

 Pandora is uninteresting to me thus far aside from wanting to know WHY she said reality had to be rewritten at the end of Flashpoint.  Don't care about Phantom Stranger, this Question isn't Renee Montoya so I don't care, I have not been impressed one bit with Justice League of America thus far, so sadly I am heading to Trinity War with very low expectations. Maybe...as was the case with the Atlantis arc in JL...this will work in my favor and I will be overjoyed by its quality!



And finally let me just say that I am super excited for this one though and a lot of the reason comes from this excerpt from an IGN interview Batman writer Scott Snyder did here


Snyder: What happened was, I started thinking about all the things we never saw in Batman: Year One; the adventures and the early years of Bruce that had been unexplored -- a lot of the first things that happened to him. I was kind of planning on telling a story about that at some point. Then what happened – and this is me just being totally honest with you, Joey, and I guess everybody out there reading [laughs] – is that I realized over the last five or six months that a lot of the things I was trying to work around from Year One, in my story, didn’t track anymore with the present day continuity of the [New] 52.

Meaning, Jim Gordon’s son, James, would be five or six years old. And believe me, nobody loves Year One more than me. Using that book as a foundation of what you build on is hugely important to me. But, Selina Kyle’s origin is different, Barbara Gordon’s origin is different, the Falcone family is different. All of that stuff is different, and so what happened was it became, “Do I do this more tepid early years story that tries very hard to work around the elements of Year One that we could actually show again to show that they exist still and just retread?” Or does it become about saying, “I’m going to be respectful of Year One and the things that I love, but try and do something with Greg that’s our own and shows you how Batman became Batman in the 52?

As I have said before, with the history of the Bat & GL franchises theoretically left intact with the reboot a whole slew of problems were presented but left unaddressed.  As Snyder stated, when the New 52 history began to unfold, characters new origins didn't vibe with that idea so well.  It's refreshing to hear that addressed by the guy spearheading the Bat-Verse and I like that he is making an attempt to do something along these line.  As much of a continuity whore as I can be though, I don't want to see a story that is just a point-by-point history book and I am not so stuck on what carried over from the Old DCU, I just would expect everything within the New 52 to make sense.  Create your rules and then follow them...that's a simple guideline for creating any fantasy realm and the New 52 has shown more than a few hiccups (I'm looking at you Scott Lobdell and your faux-Tim Drake).  Maybe that's why I find it funny that Snyder specifically said this in the interview though, "This is not, 'Why is Damian as old as he is?'"

I keep trying to remind myself that the New 52 is only two years old and that it took an eternity for Marvel and DC to really cement their universes in the first place.  I just wonder, and probably always will, if anyone from DC sat down and thought out the finer points the way Bendis did with Hank Pym's AoU death here?

Anyway, I kind of hope that the idea of Zero Year catches on for some of the other New 52 books and that in five-ten years, when we have all hopefully finally stopped calling it the New 52, we will have some sort of idea of DCU history in the sense we all head it prior to Flashpoint.  Instead of Crisis, we will have Trinity...instead of Knightfall we will have Death of the Family...instead of Death of Superman we will have...I don't know, probably not He'l On Earth though.


Monday, October 15, 2012

Green Lantern & The New 52: Pulling on Threads...


Before I get to the meat of this one, let me take a second to harken back to my last Bat-Centric blog and point out another mention of Tim Drake as Robin from "Batman & Robin" that was pointed out to me by Brian Thomer aka @PAComicExaminer:



Also something else that has occurred to me in the light of the fact that in Batman #13 it is explicitly stated that The Joker is coming back after a year away which means that Detective Comics #1 was one year ago, which means any Zero issue story marked "One Year Ago" took place around the start of the New 52, which means Damian's "Year and a Half Ago" moment of meeting Bruce (while he was still Batman & before he disappeared for a year) took place around 6 months prior to the beginning of the New 52, which means he has only been Robin for very a short time at the start of the New 52, which means it would be quite difficult for Dick to have been Batman for a year, which means I am going to make my f'n head explode trying to make sense out of it meaning sometimes I wish I could still think like I did when I was a little kid and not really care about this all continuity making some semblance of sense. End scene...

Waiiiiiiiit a second, another thing came out during NYCC after I wrote that opening paragraph, something playing into all that.  Courtesy of Bleeding Cool, Dan DiDio, Jim Lee, and Bob Wayne claimed that Tim Drake was NEVER intended to be a Robin and that the trade edits were intended to maintain the status quo they wanted in the first place.  Okay well,  I'm not going to argue my personal feelings on the whole "Not Robin" idea but rather point out that both the 1st New 52 Batman collection AND Batman & Robin collection came out with references to Tim as Robin before the edited Teen Titans collection came out. 

SO if the "Not Robin" stance on Tim was ALWAYS intended, then who fucked up A YEAR AGO when the New 52 began and then fucked up again in May & June when the collections were released? I mean did the ball get dropped by numerous people here or did the top level forget to tell everyone else that Tim was never supposed to be a Robin?  Too much to get DC Comics to just say "yup, we fucked up"?  Regularly scheduled program time now...


I almost feel like I should start this off by saying that I am a big fan of Green Lantern with Geoff Johns at the helm.  Prior to the day I was given "Rebirth" as a gift, I hadn't really kept up with the adventures of GL in his own book and aside from reading Hal Jordan in "Death of Superman", the only GL I had every really known was Kyle Rayner via his inclusion on the JLA team first penned by Grant Morrison.

Suffice to say that I was hooked and quickly got my hands on the "Emerald Twilight" story to see what happened with Hal Jordan as I had experienced his villainous side in "Zero Hour" and other major stories like his sacrifice to reignite the sun in "Final Night" and his dawning as The Spectre in "Day of Judgement".

After reading "GL: Rebirth", I quickly snatched up all of the collections I could, caught up just in time for the finale of the "Sinestro Corps War", and have continued to read the core book as well as "Green Lantern Corps", "Emerald Warriors", "Red Lanterns", and "The New Guardians". From the original DCU into The New 52, I have followed the exploits of Hal Jordan, Kyle Rayner, Guy Gardner, John Stewart, and the rest of the GLC. 

I have enjoyed the story within the GL book probably more in the New 52 than I did in the latter months of the Original DCU. Sadly the same can't be said for GLC, The New Guardians, or Red Lanterns, at least not initially, but GLC & New Guardians have turned a corner for me in recent months.  Unfortunately I still find Red Lanterns to be a chore to read and if it wasn't for the manner in which I read it, I would have stopped long ago...

Now that the pleasantries and whatnot are out of the way, let me get down to the meat of the thing....my exploration of the threads that make up the current Green Lantern universe and what happens if you follow them back to their origins.


This is where the current face of the Green Lantern corner of the DCU was born...the day Coast City was annihilated by the machinations of The Cyborg Superman Hank Henshaw & Mongul.  Some would argue it began here...


...and that the story started there runs all the way through to this...


...and continues into the most recent issue #13. Yes, I do believe that that belief is right, but only partly right, even my thought that it began with the destruction of Coast City is only PART of the story.  See I firmly believe that the current face of the GL-verse, the face that Geoff Johns has worked so hard to construct, is quite dependant on a number of factors that pre-date his time in DC Comics and thus, obviously, pre-date the creation of the New 52.  This is not a statement on the quality of the New 52, this is not a judgement on the story that HAS Been told thus far in the last year.  Rather it is my look at the events of the Old DCU that played into the formation of the GL Johns-verse and my wondering how/if they fit into the New 52.

First up:


The Anti-Monitor & The Original Crisis.  This might seem like an odd place to begin but it is one of the two most essential elements of the current GL-scape in the New 52.  As we have learned over the last year, the events of Blackest Night still happened in some format in the world of the New 52.  Whether or not they are absolutely identical is not known, but highly unlikely given the involvement of the JSA members and the fact that the death of one Barry Allen (who obviously hasn't died in the the New 52) was a part of the story. 
Well at the core of the Blackest Night story, or rather at the core of the Black Lanterns was a certain BL Battery on the planet Ryut, the battery that powered the zombie tribe, just like the one on Oa powers the Green Lanterns.  Well the power source of that battery was none other than the Anti-Monitor!  How did he end up there you ask?

Well that makes another aspect of a certain old DCU story required in some format or another, and that story is none other than the Sinestro Corps War!  See in the Sinestro Corps War, the Anti-Monitor was part of an alliance of Sinestro, the Cyborg Superman, Superboy-Prime, and the Parallax entity (brought to "life" by possessing Kyle Rayner).  As the SCW neared its conclusion, the Anti-Monitor was near defeat following the detonation of the Central Yellow Lantern battery and was ultimately tossed into space by Superboy-Prime where the Anti-Monitor crash landed on Ryut and was consumed by the BL Battery.

Why did Superboy-Prime toss Anti-Monitor into space you ask?  Well that is also very dependant another aspect of the Old CU, probably the most important story in the history of the Old DCU actually, Crisis on Infinite Earths.  See Superboy-Prime was a resident of Earth-Prime where he was the only superhero of that Earth but it was destroyed by the Anti-Monitor during the Crisis.  Prime joined up with the heroes of Earth-One to stop Anti-Monitor but is exiled to a "paradise" dimension along with three others from alternate Earths including a Lois Lane & Superman from Earth-2 and Alexander Luthor from Earth-3.  Once there he grows frustrated and his punching of the walls of reality create changes including the resurrection of Jason Todd and inconsistent origins of Superman over the years. Eventually he, along with his trio, break free from their "prison" and the subsequent events are known as "Infinite Crisis".  In this crisis we see Superboy (the clone Superman) die, Superboy-Prime go nuts and kill a lot of people, and eventually get locked up inside the Science Cells on Oa.

Wait, what's up with the Superboy who is a clone of Superman you ask?

See that leads to the other story of the Old DCU that I believe is absolutely crucial to the mythos of the current GL-verse:


Superman died...killed at the hands of Doomsday, between the first issue of the New 52 Swamp Thing and recent comments by Grant Morrison at a comic-con, we can confirm that Superman died AND was in fact killed by Doomsday in the New 52.  Beyond that, the question is very much up in the air...well, to an extent.  It is safe to say that in the New 52, the Return/Reign of Superman story did NOT happen in anyway similar to how it happened in the Old DCU.  Superboy was only "born" around the time the New 52 started, meaning he could not have taken part in any story prior to this and Steel in the New 52 is not of the same origin as the original which we've seen in Grant Morrison's Action Comics. No clue if the Eradicator or Hank Henshaw have existed in the New 52, but in SOME FASHION this story needs to have taken place because it is where Coast City was blown up the Cyborg Superman & Mongul.

Why is it so integral that Coast City blew up?

Well Coast City's destruction is what set all the wheels in motion that brought us to this day as far as Hal Jordan's character go.  Hal went nuts following the events of Coast City, tried to use his ring to resurrect the city, but was shut down by the Guardians.  Hal then went to Oa to try and get the power he wanted and ultimately ends up killing all the Guardians save Ganthet as well as Lantern Killowog and the rogue Sinestro who had been imprisoned in the Green Lantern Battery.  Hal takes the name Parallax, tries to rewrite time in Zero Hour, sacrifices his life to reignite the sun in Final Night, becomes the Spectre in Day of Judgement, and that all lead to his resurrection in Rebirth. 

So within the story of Hal Jordan, just to get to what Geoff Johns established in Rebirth, we need Hal to decimate Oa (very likely because we saw a trashed Oa in the New 52 version of GLC #1 prior to Kyle Rayner getting his ring) and for Sinestro to be freed.  We need Hal to have been possessed by the Parallax entity, for it to have somehow survived his sacrifice to reignite the sun (as it did in the Old DCU) and for Hal to have been Spectre with the Parallax entity riding shotgun.

It has been established courtesy of Phantom Stranger #0 that The Spectre exists in the New 52 but, at least in its initial appearance, it is Jim Corrigan who is possessed by The Spectre.  Now this happens at some non-descript time but I couldn't imagine DC introducing Corrigan as the character in the Zero issue only to have him NOT still be Spectre in the following issues. 

I'm not even touching on the issues that play into the history of the assorted Earth GL's.  Did Xanshi still get destroyed in order to shape the character of John Stewart and actually give added weight to his destruction of Mogo (a pre-New 52 event btw)?  Was Kyle Rayner still possessed by the Ion entity or does his New 52 tag of Torchbearer have some different meaning?  Was Guy Gardner still in possession of a yellow ring at an earlier point in his career (it seems he was still possessed by a red ring)?

Those are all just pieces of the Old DCU that play heavily into the shape of the New 52 and while I've chosen to focus on the GL-Verse, specifically Hal Jordan, in this rant, I think it is safe to say that DC's decision to keep GL & Bat history relatively intact creates some problems with elements of the Old DCU.  For GL these are what I consider the key ingredients to have happened IN SOME FASHION for the shape of the current New 52 world:

1) The existence of an Anti-Monitor (power source for BL battery)
2) Coast City destroyed
3) Hal Jordan as Parallax, destroying Oa (partially confirmed)
4) Hal Jordan freeing Sinestro & Parallax entity from the Power Battery
5) Hal Jordan as Spectre
6) Sinestro Corps War happened
7) Blackest Night happened (this has been confirmed)
8) War of the Green Lanterns happened (Krona needs to exist for the events of Red Lanterns)

I am sure I am missing something here as I am trying to do this from memory as opposed to notes this time, but I hope you get the idea.  There are just certain key elements with the Old DCU that had to have happened in some fashion for the current Geoff Johns/GL-Verse to really make sense.  They don't have to be perfect, they don't have to have happened completely identical to the way they happened in the Old DCU, but they do have to have happened somehow. 

Coast City must die, Hal Jordan must have been evil...they are as important as Luke Skywalker seeing Obi-Wan die on the Death Star in "A New Hope" or Dexter being found in a pool of his mother's blood on "Dexter".  They are integral components of an origin story that I had hoped the Zero issues would be used to confirm or flesh out, but sadly that was not in any of the four GL series.  GL #0 told us the origin of a new character, New Guardians #0 gave us nothing origin-based, Red Lanterns #0 was a serious waste, and only GLC #0 gave us anything origin based and, while I enjoyed the look at Guy's back story, it did not fill in any of the blanks I have discussed above.

This isn't a cry for answers, not yet at least, rather this was just an exploration into how the Old DCU events could/should tie into the events of the New 52.  I will be very interested to see if DC Comics does anything to cement any aspects of the old world as part of the new, or if they find a way to rewrite these histories in a logical fashion.

Thus far they have done a subpar job with the Bat-world, creating inconsistencies in time and logic, particularly with the birth of Damian Wayne and their lack of a backbone on the Tim "Drake"/Robin situation as mentioned at the start of this rant.

I hope maybe, just maybe, they will solidify the ground on which the New 52 Green Lantern world is built rather than just the half-assed "everything still happened" explanation we have gotten over the last year.  I know it's a lot to cover in just 14 months of time, but I sincerely hope that maybe in the next 13 months the portrait of GL history is painted with more clarity.










Tuesday, September 4, 2012

The New 52 (One Year Later...More or Less)


August 31, 2011....that marked the day that the Old DCU came to an end with "Flashpoint" and the day the New 52 was born with Justice League #1.  So as of the day of this writing, September 3rd, it has been...

- 369 days  (not counting today)
1 year, 33 days
-  31,881,600 seconds
- 531,360 minutes
- 8856 hours
- 52 weeks (rounded down)

Since I'm spitting out facts & figures, let me run those down before I get into the nitty gritty of this piece...ya know the part where I rant about the things I loved, liked, and hated.

So we started with 52 core books, the ones indicated in that banner right up there, but it was announced in January 2011 that the following "First Wave" books would be cancelled after eight issues:

- Mister Terrific
- Static Shock
- Hawk and Dove
- OMAC
- Blackhawks
- Men of War

Those titles were replaced with the "Second Wave" of the New 52 made up of:

- Batman Incorporated
- Earth 2
- Worlds' Finest
- Dial H
- GI Combat
- The Ravagers

Then we had a second wave of cancellations over the course of August & September, most of these ending at a #0 issue, consisting of:

- Justice League International
- Captain Atom
- Resurrection Man
- Voodoo

And now we've got the "Third Wave" kicking off in September as well with all of the following starting their runs with #0 issues:

- Talon
- Sword of Sorcery
- The Phantom Stranger
- Team 7

So obviously DC is trying to stick with a core of 52 on-going books but there are a slew of mini's, one-shots, and now a "National Comics" anthology that aren't considered part of this number for various reasons, but the one being the ability to say "we only publish 52 books" would be the top of the list I imagine.

Now as for the most important part, for the companies at least, and the primary reason for any company to do anything of this magnitude: sales!  Here's a look at the July 2012 sales charts which are the most recent:

Retail Market Share -
DC Comics - 32.71%
Marvel - 31.96%

Unit Market Share -
DC Comics - 36.55%
Marvel Comics - 35.45%

One year earlier, prior to the start of the New 52, it was the exact opposite:

Retail market Share-
- Marvel 43.59
- DC 30.55%
 
Unit Market Share
- Marvel 43.59%
- DC 34.76%
 
 
So with the top ten in July 2012, DC had 6 of the top 10 spots and 11 of the top 20 compared to Marvel's 3 of the top 10 and 8 of the top 20 (all of Marvel's were tied into AVX somehow). The lone spot not belonging to Marvel or DC was the #1 and that was owned by Image's "The Walking Dead" #100.

One year earlier it was Marvel with 5 of the top 10, DC with 5, and Marvel with 12 of the top 20 while DC had 8 of that 20.

So I think it's safe to say that comparing the one year later numbers, DC did something right in generating interest in SOME of their books. There are still some books, like Grifter, Blue Beetle, & DC Universe Presents that have somehow survived the axe despite sales for their #11 issues hovering around 13,000 while books like Resurrection Man and Justice League International are getting chopped despite better numbers (14,715 & 29,802 respectively).

Personally I don't get the decision to chop the former because it's something different & unique in the DCU and with the latter it seems...based on the recent Justice League of America announcement...that the choice to kill JLI has more to do with future plans than anything the book has done wrong.
 
So it seems from a financial stand-point that DC made a good decision in this reboot but what about creatively? Well, now that I've got the BS out of the way...it's time for me to address what's worked for me and what hasn't in the form of a Best & Worst List!!!
 
 
Best of the New 52
Batman (obviously)
 
For me, and for a whole lot of folks, this has been the standout book of the New 52. With a very strong writer in Scott Snyder and art by Greg Capullo that shocked the hell out of me in how awesome it has been, "Batman" is the best example of taking what existed prior to the reset, honoring it, but continuing on with a story that didn't require new fans to know the decades of history that existed in the Old DCU. With the Court of Owls, Snyder played within the confines of what old fans know has always existed but brought us into a darkened corner of that room, illuminating it for the very first time. The Court's existence never felt shoehorned into Bruce's, or Batman's, life...well maybe a little with the back-up that ran through Night of the Owls...and it seemed like if fit right into the seams of Gotham, as if it was indeed right in front of readers for all this time but we never noticed it...just like Bruce.
 
Capullo, who I knew from Spawn & X-Force but hadn't seen on a book in forever, was the main question mark I had going into this but my doubts were very, very quickly rendered inert by the amazing work he did in everything from simple faces to page layouts. He made the Court feel horrifying, a feeling often hard to generate in comics, and made Bruce seem fragile at times...another difficult feat to pull off as well. This is the book I look most forward to every month, and cannot wait
until The Joker arc kicks off in October!
 

 Animal Man (left) & Swamp Thing (right)
 
These were both books I discovered after what many declare their creative heyday (Animal Man by Grant Morrison & Alan Moore's Swamp Thing) but those arcs quickly became two of my all-time faves, which is retroactively amusing to me with Animal Man because he was also one of my favorite aspects of the "52" maxi-series which I read way before I ever touched Animal Man.

Unfortunately these were two properties essentially dead in the Old DCU, more so Buddy Baker.  Animal Man had been relegated to an afterthought post-"52", popping up randomly in JLA stories, while Swamp Thing was seemingly in the midst of a rebirth via the "Brightest Day" maxi-series & "Search For Swamp Thing" which returned Constantine to the DCU proper after having been exclusively a Vertigo character since 1993. The "Search" book sucked...

So when the announcements of the New 52 titles came around these were two books I was psyched for, Swamp Thing because of the creative team of Scott Snyder & Yannick Paquette and Animal Man because an interview I read with Jeff Lemire essentially said he was shooting for a Morrison-esque take on Buddy Baker. Sold on both titles!

And I must say that these two books are what I would think the New 52 was all about as they took two properties that were essentially obscure to the general public and made them two of the most successful books both creatively AND financially.  In the July '12 sales, Animal Man #11 ranked 60 and Swamp Thing #11 was 55.  Not bad for two books on the fringe really...and the way the two books have been interlaced with one another, and with their pre-New 52 history, almost since the beginning has been masterful. The concepts of the Red & Green are ones forged in the Old DCU, the history between Swampy & The Arcanes is old territory, but it has all been introduced as freshly as possible to the uninitiated audience.  Hell I give Swamp Thing lots of points just based on the fact that it was the first, and maybe still the only, book to acknowledge that Superman did indeed die in the New 52:



 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The two books have been on a collision course since jump street and have finally reached that convergence with the "Rotworld" arc that begins in September and it has been a tremendous ride so far watching Buddy and his family, experiencing Alec Holland reluctantly embrace his destiny, and that's not even mentioning the amazing artistic work by Travel Foreman on Animal Man & Paquette on Swamp Thing.  They have defined the visuals of this new world and, honestly, Animal Man doesn't seem the same without Foreman. Now that was an artistic switch I was dreading but am adjusting to now.  This pair of "Dark" books are two of my highest recommend titles in the New 52 in large part because of how it took the obscure characters and made them top tier.

Aquaman
 
"Aquaman" on the other hand is a great example of taking a mainstream character, one who is kind of derided and mocked, and turning him into an uber-badass by tackling those jibes head-on.  Right from the first issue Geoff Johns works his magic, the same way he did on Green Lantern, and begins to change all of the preconceived notions of just who Aquaman is by basically having the randoms he encounters point out all their inaccurate beliefs. Johns even has an Aquaman fan quizzing Arthur on exactly what his powers are and how he feels about being the guy that no-one takes seriously.
 
So what does Johns do in response? Show everyone, the fans and characters alike, just how awesomely powerful Aquaman is and with each issue continues to demonstrate why he deserves to be considered one of the Big Seven.  The issues read fast, and are an absolute beauty to look at with the Ivan Reis art.  He is without a doubt one of my absolute favorites working for DC right now, up there with Doug Manhke, JH Williams III, Capullo, and Foreman..artists whose work is just stunning to look at for a varied reasons.  This, as with Swampy and Animal Man, is a great example of just how the New 52 should work to reinvigorate/redefine a character.
 
Honorable Mentions:
- Batgirl
- Green Lantern
- Batwoman's 1st Arc
- Nightwing
- Wonder Woman
 
Worst of the New 52
 
Hawkman
 
This is without a doubt the biggest disappointment of the entire New 52 for me.  I have long been a fan of the idea of Hawkman dating back to my first real exposure to the character during "Zero Hour" and the subsequent series that followed.  Yet as with nearly every iteration of the character I have read, save his role in "JSA" and "Brightest Day", the idea of Hawkman was a lot more interesting than the actual execution of the character.  Johns did a decent job in his handling of Carter in the aforementioned JSA book but that didn't carry over to his solo spin-off book and I dropped that after about a year. 
 
So I had my hopes up for a New 52 version of the character, one with all of that utterly confusing origin wiped away.  Instead what I got was a really wtf first issue with Carter trying to burn the costume for whatever reason accompanied by some really awful art from Phillip Tan. Bad dialogue, bad art, and an opening sequence that is never addressed in the six issues I managed to tolerate this book for...massive failure.  I mean Carter Hall, the archaeologist, repeatedly states he has had the Nth Metal armor for years but apparently knows absolutely nothing about it as the villains keep having to tell him things and he just generally seems clueless as to his own abilities.  I think that works with a character who we are just witnessing come into their powers like say a Blue Beetle, but not when the lead keeps expressing that he's had his abilities for years.  I lasted six issues and from everything I saw/read, things did NOT improve when Rob Liefeld came onto the book...but that's a whole other issue for later.
 
Superman
 
Call it editorial interference or whatever...the bottom line is that this book has never been good.  I have read George Perez's statements about editorial and how he didn't know what he could do because no one knew what Grant Morrison was doing with the history-based "Action Comics", and I am sure that had a direct effect on the story Perez wanted to tell.  Does it excuse the story he ended up telling though?  I just found this book pointless and boring and it just felt old...the exact opposite of what a flagship book should feel like and that exact opposite of the feeling that Batman was, and still is, generating. 
 
The change in writers did nothing to improve the quality of the book either, despite it being Dan Jurgens who piloted Supes through his Death & Rebirth, as we got tie-ins to Wildstorm characters, a character whose name was originally Masochist but got changed to Anguish because the former was too controversial I guess, and then I stopped because I just didn't care anymore.  The art was fine I suppose, but this was a book that just felt...detached...that might be the best word, yeah detached from any other depiction of Superman we were seeing in the New 52. And the worst crime of all...it was BORING, the antithesis of everything your flagship character should be and that is why it makes my Worst Of section.
 
The Ravagers
 
 
So initially I thought I would keep my judgement to the books that had a decent shelf life to judge but when my brain keeps coming back to one book, I had to bring it up.  "The Ravagers" is bad spin-off from a really bad "Superboy", "Teen Titans", "Legion Lost" crossover that was so bad it made me stop paying for Teen Titans, insured I would never pay for Superboy, and guaranteed I would never read a Legion issue ever.  So that sounds like the perfect recipe for a spin-off doesn't it?  This book, perhaps more than any other, just screams of 90s Marvel with its creative team and it reads like it too...in all the bad ways.  There is little redeemable about any of these characters, I hate this usage of Beast Boy after falling in love with the character as a result of Geoff Johns' Teen Titans book, and I found this book so repulsive I lasted all of two issues.  They were two issues of just terrible dialogue and plot.  This is the only blight on the "2nd Wave" as I really like "Earth 2" and "World's Finest" (don't really consider Batman Inc. a New 52 book as I will explain shortly).  This book should just be set on fire....
 
Dishonorable Mentions
- Deathstroke as soon as Liefeld took over
- Superboy
- Green Arrow
- The Dark Knight (prior to #9)
 
Most Improved
 
Red Hood & The Outlaws
 
I can see getting flack for this one but I think this book has made a strong turn-around since its highly criticized debut...criticism that centered around the depiction of Starfire as a brain-dead sex kitten and criticism that was rightfully deserved.  Regardless of what Lobdell tried to claim a year ago, I think any growth in that character, and evolving her into the warrior princess she is know being depicted as, was a direct response to the extreme backlash he received after this issue hit stands. 
 
For that reason as well as the vapid depiction of Roy Harper (a character I fell in love with through Judd Winick's "Outsiders") I just about dropped the book after the third issue.  Yet something kept me going, and that something was watching the character of Jason Todd grow before my eyes.  Now JT is a character I have undying love for ever since Winick's Red Hood arc and I am always excited to see him used by a writer.  He was the draw for me to this book, and Lobdell's spin on the bastard Robin kept me coming back for more despite Arsenal having no purpose for existing and in spite of how Starfire was, at first, treated.
 
My patience has been rewarded I feel as I have watched Starfire grow into a more full character and I have enjoyed watching JT dance on the fringes of the Bat Universe as well and am quite excited for this book's Zero issue as well as it's involvement in the Joker story in coming months.  It has been fun to watch this motley crew grow into something resembling a family, now I only hope that Lobdell actually gives us some rationale as to why Harper is hanging around...he just doesn't seem to belong yet.
 
Suicide Squad, for a few months, was a contender for this one but pretty much went to pot after (maybe even during) the Harley Quinn arc and Catwoman was up there too, especially considering its similarly controversial sexy start, but it just hasn't maintained that upward momentum so I wouldn't put it in there either.

Honorables
- Green Lantern Corps
- The New Guardians
- Batman: The Dark Knight (Starting with #9)
 
Biggest Disappointment
Teen Titans

Undoubtedly, unequivocally this has been the biggest of the New 52 for me despite having the same author as my "most improved" (but also having the same author as one of my worst).  I love Tim Drake, he is my Robin, meaning that he was Robin when I started reading comics and maintained that role for the vast majority of my time as a reader.  It's kind of like how Hal Jordan is some people's GL or maybe it's Kyle, or Wally West is your Flash (certainly mine) as opposed to Barry Allen.

Well that desire to follow the exploits of Tim Drake is what pulled me into Teen Titans and I think this is the book that I had to convince myself that I liked for the first few issues.  I mean there were some moments that I liked, the inclusion of Morrison's Danny the Street character from Doom Patrol for example, and I am a sucker for Bret Booth's art , but on the whole it was just lacking.  The story wasn't there for me, didn't give a damn about Brick or Skitter or Solstice, Superboy is an ass, and that was all before the god awful crossover with Superboy & Legion Lost.  That was the straw that broke my back because it was terrible in every sense...story, art, purpose...everything. 

Oh and Lobdell had to go and state that the Zero ish will reveal Tim Drake was never a Robin...despite stating that he was a Robin in the very first issue of this book as well as it being mentioned in a few other places like so:




Which brings me to my next topic of discussion...what's the biggest thing wrong with the New 52...

Continuity Problems
 
This is something I've blogged about before (here & here) and it is something that continues to plague the New 52 one year later.  How do you cram this much crap in five years time?  We've got the birth of superheroes which is essentially chronicled in Justice League, the birth of Superman which is chronicled in Action Comics and takes place one year...ish...prior to Justice League, or at least it did at first, now it seems to be running somewhat concurrent with JL - Year One.  
 
We had multiple Crisis events in the Old DC but those are now longer canon apparently, but the problem there arises when you look at some of the necessary details that I addressed in the previous blogs, most importantly the existence of The Anti-Monitor & Superboy Prime as their existence is absolutely crucial to Hal Jordan's story unfolding as it did from Rebirth going forward.  See Anti-Monitor & Superboy-Prime were crucial parts of the Original Crisis, Prime was an integral part of Infinite Crisis, both were necessary to the Sinestro Corps War Story which was also 1000000% necessary, especially the fate of Anti-Monitor, to the Blackest Night story which we know is still canon because the current GL story is still playing off threads that Geoff Johns initiated when GL: Rebirth first started. 
 
But wait...what about all that...that all requires Hal Jordan to have died, which requires Hal to have been possessed by Parallax and gone bat-shit and destroyed the Central Power Battery to free Parallax & Sinestro which requires Coast City to have been destroyed which requires the existence of Cyborg Superman & Mongul which requires Superman to have died which requires Doomsday to have existed which requires ancient Kryptonians to have created him.
 
Which means the DCU is the worst place you could ever possibly choose to live because all of that happened in five years time.  Imagine Batman's world.... if everything remains intact he became Batman, Dick Grayson became Robin then Nightwing, Jason Todd became Robin then died then came back and became Red Hood, Tim Drake found out the secret, became Robin, his parents were killed, later he became Red Robin, Damian Wayne was born and aged ten years then became Robin, Barbara Gordon was paralyzed, Bruce was paralyzed by Bane, Jean Paul Valley became Batman, Bruce took his mantle back, there was a plague, there was round two of the plague, an earthquake, No Man's Land, a Gang War, Hush, the entire Black Glove conspiracy, a trip through time courtesy of Darkseid's Omega Effect, Dick Grayson becoming Batman after fighting it out with Jason Todd, Bruce reclaiming his mantle and finding out his big enemy is actually his relative hundreds of years removed. 
 
...Five years...
 
Of all those events what do we know for certain happened?  Well we know via flashbacks from Guy Gardner that the Anti-Monitor existed, we know from Swamp Thing that Superman died, we know that Bane broke Batman's back, we know Dick Grayson was Batman for roughly a year for some unexplained New 52 reason. We know that Blackest Night happened in some fashion and well, that pretty much everything Geoff Johns has done in the GL-verse seems intact. 
 
I would go so far as to say it almost feels as if the events in Green Lantern are taking place in some other world because it feels totally removed from the rest of the DCU, and the Hal Jordan in this book bears little resemblance to the one in Justice League.  The same can pretty much be said for every character in the Justice League, save Cyborg because he is undoubtedly a token presence in the League based on how unimportant he seems to the group, and doesn't exist anywhere else outside that book.  The characterization of the other 6 in no way reads like the fashion in which they are being written in their own books, and there's something to be said for that when Johns writes JL, GL, and Aquaman.  How does he get the voices to wrong from one to the next?  It's just one of the problems I have with Justice League...another being how I am excited for what I think is coming but not excited for the actual story that I am reading month-to-month.  The story I have in my head...the one in which the JL know that something isn't right with this timeline...that is more interesting to me than anything Johns has served up so far.
 
Anywho, these inconsistencies have been the biggest problem with the New 52 overall as a lot of lip service was given to the idea of world building but I would be hard-pressed to think that the Wonder Woman & Green Lantern as written in their own title exist in any world shared by the Superman & Batman in their books.  Hell, it would be hard convincing met that the Supes in Action & the one in Superman reside in the same reality....
 
I think, to rectify so many of these problems, DC needs to establish some key things about these characters histories, in particular for the big guns who haven't been utterly rewritten.  I think it's safe to say Wonder Woman's story is a totally new one in the New 52 but it seems important to flesh out the events in the life of a Superman or Batman or Green Lantern. 
 
In some ways it seems as if DC would have had an easier time handling this, and probably gotten less flack from fans, if they had gone all the way with the reboot and wiped slates clean across the board, especially when you have a book like "Batman Inc." that just seems to dance with whatever continuity it feels like bringing to the dance that issue.  It seems as if the "2nd Wave" version is picking up 100% where it left off, but then we've got a character like Batwing who "died" in the original Inc run but has been running around the New 52 since the beginning and yet in the new Inc are still talking like he faked his death.  My head hurts....
 
A new "Who's Who" or "History of the DC Universe" might solve a lot of these problems, but DC needs to be willing to stick to whatever new history they establish, even if it means erasing certain  parts of a character's story that were beloved in the Old DCU.  In doing so though, they have to make sure they are aware of the butterfly effect of continuity...like how do we get to Blackest Night if Superman never died & the Original Crisis didn't happen? Or how did Dick Grayson become Batman if Bruce Wayne was never sent into history by Darkseid to essentially create himself?  It can be a sticky situation when you follow the individual story threads back to their origin points...
 
So to wrap up this diatribe, let me say that I am still...one year later...mixed on the New 52.  Obviously it has been successful from a financial standpoint, and creatively it has seen some boons as well, but those story achievements are all ones that could have been done within the confines of the Old DCU.  There is nothing about Swamp Thing or Animal Man that couldn't have been done prior to Flashpoint, the Court of Owls idea certainly existed prior to the reboot, and Aquaman could have gotten the "rebirth" treatment at anytime. 
 
Sure DC might have had some problems melding the Wildstorm world into the DCU in the Old World, but seriously, has ANYTHING ported over from Wildstorm been good?  Stormwatch started with some promise but that floundered...Grifter nope...Voodoo cancelled...I guess we will see what happens with Team 7. 
 
And as far as that continuity stuff goes, let's see if the Zero issues starting this week answer any questions for us.  I am not holding my breath for that...just hoping for a few good yarns is all.  It will be interesting to see where we are with the New 25 in another year with the Trinity War on the horizon as well as the spawning of the Justice League of America title, and this underlying thread that all is not right with the Justice League and the future will go tragically because Supes & WW kissed (which btw, I thought was devoid of feeling).
 
Just like one year ago, I am excited and apprehensive but I think it is the second one winning out...
 

 
 

Tuesday, February 7, 2012

Batman: The Grant Morrison Odyssey - Phase Four



Well this is going to be an interesting one for me to take one because, unlike the previous blogs where I took everything on in the order it was published, I am going to make an attempt to take this one on in the chronological order it took place....which is a total trip considering it's spread out over three different collections, "RIP", "Final Crisis", and "Time and the Batman".  I said in the previous blog that "RIP" was kind of the close of the first arc of Morrison's larger story, and these stories are the reason I said kind of.  I felt differently after I finished up though, but I'll address that when we're all said and done with this installment.  So first let me get the obligatory links out of the way, and then we shall get this bad boy started!

Part 1: Batman & Son
Part 2: Club of Heroes & Resurrection of Ra's Al Ghul
Part 2.1: Devil-Bats & The Bridge to RIP
Part 3: RIP


Just like Bruce, the reader dives right into this story at the point where Bruce's part in "RIP" ended.  A bit of a trip considering that this is issue #701 and that particular story ended with #681.  In-between we had the "Last Rites" story (more on those in a bit) as well as the adventures of Dick Grayson & Damian as Batman & Robin for over a year.  See what I mean about how reading this in chronological-story order can be difficult?

So where we last left Bruce he was apparently consumed in the fiery crash of a helicopter manned by Devil-Bats & Dr. Hurt (who may or may not be Bruce's dad Thomas).  Unseen in this particular crop of that image above is the "Days to Omega: 30" countdown which (given that this was published post-Final Crisis) tells the reader how far in advance of that fateful story these moments are taking place. It's a useful tool considering how much of the question floated around at the time of when RIP & FC took place relative to one another.

The narrative is once again written in the form of a casebook log, intriguing given that we know how this all ends up, leaving a question of just when/how this was written, as well as giving us insight into the mental state of Bruce following the chaos of RIP.  One of the paragraphs also gives us a time stamp, informing us of the duration of the story as Bruce laments "I tried not to think about the last five days--wandering the streets of Gotham, deranged, poisoned, deceived."

The title page also provides some focus with a story dubbed "The Hole In Things" which is just what Dr. Hurt referred to himself as, and the image of the bat also laid over with the gun & pearl necklace that are synonomous with the murder of Bruce's parents.

Bruce emerges from the water sans cape & cowl, but of course he has a spare in his utility belt, he's the goddamn Batman after all!  He's met....in a nice touch...by the hooker from "Batman & Son" that he gave a WayneTech business card to, and she informs him that she has taking a job as a receptionist, that something as simple as Bats remembering her name helped changed her life.


Bruce arrives home, Alfred...black eye and all...waits for him, and we get some more insight into just what happened in "RIP".  Bruce's bout of insanity was due to him miscalculating the dose of Joker Anti-Venom & he confirms that both he & Alfred suspected Jezebel Jet's involvement in the whole scenario.  Still, no rest for the wicked as Bruce takes a sub to the depths of the harbor in search of Hurt or Devil-Bats, and speculates on Hurt's words, "I AM THE HOLE IN THINGS...THE PIECE THAT CAN NEVER FIT."

It was a nagging statement, one that put some spectre of a supernatural nature over Dr. Hurt and his identity.  It was something Bruce couldn't shake, something that haunted his dreams as he recovered from the drugs he'd been dosed with by The Black Glove.  Bruce wanders the halls of his own home as if a stranger, referencing how Hurt found some hidden room apparently behind the picture of Thomas & Martha, a room he promised his parents to never enter, and felt obligated to apologize for as he broke that vow.

Inside the room, scrawled across the walls in...blood maybe...was the name "Thomas" and one word writtten over the top: "Barbatos".  The pages of the casebook here allude to a "sickness at the root of the family tree" or "a worm at the foundations"....and as a long-time Batman reader may remember, the name "Barbatos" initially popped up in Peter Milligan's "Dark Knight, Dark City" story from 1990, a story where a late 18th century cult in Gotham tries to bring the demon Barbathos to life.  It was recently reprinted and looks like this:


Go buy it...great story, especially if you're a Riddler fan. Anyway, it's after the revelation of this hidden room that things get really interesting/confusing/complicated as the events of "RIP: The Missing Chapter" dovetail into the events of "Final Crisis" with Alfred's statement to Bruce that "...there's something I know you'll want to see." With 27 days until Omega, the skies have turned red (DC's surefire sign of a crisis-level event) and Superman contacts Bruce about someone killing a god (in this case Orion of the New Gods).  It's an interesting look into Bruce's thoughts via the casebook notes as he states "Super-people. I've worked so hard to gain their respect, they sometimes forget I'm flesh and blood."

As he prepares to leave, Bruce informs Alfred of Hurt's last words to him....that the "next time you wear (the cape & cowl) will be your last"....as the casebook pages framing the panels question the identity (devil or dad) of Hurt.  Alfred hands him the cowl, discussing the rumors & allegations about the Wayne Family circulated into the press by The Black Glove, promising to sort it all out when Bruce returns...which we all know when this was printed never came to pass.  En route to the scene of the crime, Bruce reflects on the whole in things being everywhere he looks, a "trap I was so sure I'd escaped was locking into place all around me".


With that last panel of #701, and the first page of #702, we crash headfirst into "Final Crisis" and pages begin to overlap.  Let me state that I am not looking to address every detail of "FC" because, quite frankly, one blog isn't big enough for that.  Rather I will look at the events & elements in "FC" and how they pertain to Batman's larger story. It's too much to address the whole ice cube tray/miracle machine stuff on top of Bat-stuff.

So the first page of #702 shares space with pages of FC #1:






























Then pages #15 & 16 (ish) of FC #2 happen as Bats examines the corpse of Orion alongside Superman, Wonder Woman, Flash (Wally West), and Alpha Lantern Krakken. The Alpha insists the "backwater" technology can't possibly determine the cause of Orion's death while Batman insists that it was via gunshot wound. Watching Bats stand up to the GLC's internal affairs division is quite amusing btw...

John Stewart finds the bullet in FC #2, gets attacked, then in the 2nd & 3rd pages of #702 we see Bats investigating the bullet while the casebook blurb reads "...I'm relying on you to hear this".  Based on the page included on the left, it is safe to assume that the "you" in question is Superman.  The only question is what is he supposed to hear?

The next page of #702 showcases Bats essentially solving the question of how Orion died. He details it to Wally-Flash, how a bullet fired through backwards through time took the life of a New God and was embedded in concrete 50 years before its own creation. "Wow"

The next several pages of #702 overlap with FC #2 including these two pages, the left from Batman and the right from FC, interesting to me because it actually feels like each page contains 1/2 of a conversation between Bats & Supes.



The importance of this bullet, the way Bruce ties it into his own parents' murder, to every murder in history, is demonstrative of the way Morrison frequently looks at time...how it all takes place simultaneously, how it's all connected, how it continously births itself, the way this first bullet has birthed others.

He wraps Bruce's entire abduction scene in two different perspectives.  The straightfoward depiction in FC #2 as he realizes that Krakken has been co-opted by Darkseid and that an evil New God is essentially riding piggyback in the Alpha Lantern's body...remember that.  The depiction in #702 is done with similar art but with captions via the casebook, questioning if the attack was when "the box" opened up and how, at the moment when he was sucked into the Boom Tube, was when he "saw the shape of the trap that had been waiting for me since the day I was born".

The next page of #702 mirrors another page in FC #2 as Bruce, now the prisoner of Darksied's minions shouts to "Warn The Justice League! Warn Everyone!" and now the third collection, the "Last Rites" portion of "RIP" enters into the picture.



Now this story technically came out immediately following RIP and as such was an odd venture through an odd world.  Part flashback, part dream, part induced fantasy world, this two part story reads like Morrison finding a way to reconcile every wierd Batman story, and every depiction over the decades, into one.  We see possible outcomes if it had been something besides a bat crashing through the window that fateful night: a mothman or a snakeman for example, or as Alfred speculates, Owlman, Catman, Pigeonman, and others.  This is a jumpy, jumbled overview of the past, tied together by Alfred's frequent moments of second-guessing Bruce's decisions. 

A moment in Professor Milo's lab, memories of Dick joining the team after his parent's death, more speculation on what if Batman & Robin existed in the world of Hamlet, the original Batwoman factored into continuity for the first time since before Crisis, discussing the ever-shifting personality of the Joker, the moment of introduction to Dr. Hurt & the Isolation Experiment...and then we begin to discover that all is not what it seems...


The Lump? Quick Wiki search tells me he was another Jack Kirby creation, a foe of The New God Mister Miracle in the 70's, who Morrison has brought back for the purpose of hiding in Batman's memories as Alfred (hence the second guessing) and allowing Darkseid's minions to essentially stripmine Bat's memories.  It's an cool story convention as it allows Morrison to explore any story in Bat-continuity that he sees fit as it can all be memory.  That's why we see the original Batwoman's life & death, the real first love of Bruce's life Julie Madison, the "death" of Alfred, as well as the various (sometimes contradictory) takes on the bat-villains throughout time.  But there was something about Hurt that shook up the scenario it seems...

Bruce questions the connections between chemicals and crazy people, there's a moment of Adam West/Burt Ward-esque interaction in his memories, Joker returns to crazy, Dick becomes Nightwing, something Alfred says as he discusses a story he wrote about a world without Batman makes Bruce aware that things aren't right.  The path of memory then takes a turn into that world as Thomas Wayne stops Joe Chill from murdering them, Martha dotes on Bruce, he goes off to college, a Joker-esque attack goes down in Gotham, and a cutback to Darkseid's minions tells us just what is going on...


They are farming Batman's memories to fuel an army of Bat-Clones to "fight and die in the name of our Dark Empire"!  What a way to leave off the issue...and jump into the next issue with this...


The night of Damian's conception I suppose; followed by Bruce fighting Ra's, fighting a shark, fighting a werewolf, then getting it on with Talia once more, only to cut back to that "if Batman didn't exist" world that the previous chapter turned into.  Bruce tells Alfred about chemical racketeers killing a circus boy's parents, the joker killer torturing the boy, and Bruce feeling he could have saved him. Elements of truth filter thru The Lump's lies as Selina Kyle plays a role as a women who stole from Dr. Bruce, the well Bruce fell into as a child appears, a dog named Ace, and the odd skeleton in circus clothes...


The discovery of the bones sends The Lump into a frenzy and true memories filter through, taking us on a quick tour of Batman's past...picking up with Bruce meeting Jason Todd, his death, Barbara Gordon's shooting, in the real world the clones are killing themselves, Tim Drake finding out the secret, Bruce figuring out that the dream-Alfred isn't who he seems to be and The Lump responding by playing up horrible memories.  Bane breaking his back, recovery, fighting AzBats, the Earthquake, Hush, Jack Drake's death, culminating in a back-and-forth between Bats & The Lump...


And the revelation that it is the memories from all these traumatic experiences that truly motivates Bruce, and how it is too much for even these clones to handle as they claw their own eyes out.  Bruce realizes the chemicals he kept talking about were his brain's way of telling him he was drugged unconscious, the Lump lays dying in Bruce's mind (potentially taking Bats with him) but it is one final set of memories...the desert experience during 52, Thogal, the discovery of Damian's existence, the events of RIP....those serve as The Lump's fuel as Mokkari further points out how awesome Bruce is by asking the question "What kind of man can turn even his life memories into a weapon?"

The next page ties this story into "Missing Chapters" as this conversation takes place in both books:




I suppose it's more appropriate to say "Missing Chapter" ran into "Last Rites" since the latter was published first. A panel of the following page overlaps with the title of #702 as Bats studies the bullet in the Bat Cave, the Lump goes on a rampage in the Evil Factory which creates another tie to the story in "Missing Chapter". Before that jump I just want to point out how the captions that close out "Last Rites" belong to the true Alfred as he gives a fitting eulogy to Batman.  His comments that "...I can see him now in the grip of implacable forces, innumerable foes. Somewhere without hope..." seem especially poignant considering how we know Bruce ends up after his coming confrontation with Darkseid.

Bringing us back to where we left off in "Missing Chapter" as The Lump is decimating the lap and a semi-coherent Bruce, back to communicating via casebook captions, realizes they have done something to his mind. He express that there are "holes in his awareness and they seem to be getting bigger", and none of this could possibly be written in the moment so the question is still when did Bruce put this all to paper?



 Bruce is finding "the hole in things" everywhere, he finds the God Bullet, loads it into a gun, flashes back to the moment where Gordon asked him why he chose an enemy as old as time back in "Batman & Son", and he enters the chamber of Darkseid, running us back into Final Crisis #7 with a text bridge...


As with the fight against Krakken, the next few pages showcase the same material in different ways. The "FC" perspective is straightforward with dialogue rather than any sort of internal monologue, culminating in the "gotcha" right before the Omega Beams strike Bats down.  The "Missing Chapters" side of things provides us with the casebook excerpts, Bruce's thoughts obviously reflecting on this events from some other point, as he questions how many times this scene had played out, speculates on the "thousand extra layers of meaning" in the myth playing out in front of him.  FYI, Morrison tends to look at comic books as today's form of myth in case you haven't read any of his other work...it's a frequent theme.  Hell it's what the whole of FC seems to be about...

The "gotcha" (which felt odd in "FC") doesn't seem quite so out of place in the "Missing Chapters" take on events as it falls in line with the casebook blurb of that moment.  Batman fires one single shot from the gun using the God Bullet, and it represents the culmination of the very first moments of Morrison's Batman-run and a plot point that was brought up many times over, "Batman doesn't  use guns".  Harley & Joker both pointed it out in reference to the false-Batman who shot Joker, Batman himself points emphatically how he doesn't use guns everytime it's brought up, and here we are...in the closing moments of his life...he makes his once-in-a-lifetime exception and without it Darkseid could not have been beaten.

Those three images sum up the "Death" of Batman moments, but it's not the end of the story thanks to "Missing Chapter".  In the closing pages of this we finally discover (given that this came out over a year after the death pages) just what happened when the Omega Effect struck Batman.

Darkseid references an Ancestor-Box containing a "hyper-adapter" and tells the reader just what Omega Sanction does, creating an unbeatable "life trap" using history...essentially dumping the victim into increasingly terrible realities until they can figure out how to escape them.  The only person shown to have figured it out previously was Mister Miracle in Morrison's "Seven Soldiers"....

Bruce figures out that the trap, the box closing in around him, is time and Darkseid essentially froze him in time and spun centuries around him.  We see Bruce looking at the "Barbatos" wall in Wayne Manor (#701), observing bats flying out of  the well on the Mansion grounds & realizing his parents will die (#673), see the "funeral" from Neil Gaiman's "What Ever Happened To The Caped Crusader?" story that came out post-RIP, and Bruce seems to put things together with talk of "the grave, the well, the cave, the missing portrait"...



There's the image of Willowood Asylum which, after doing some homework, I found out was the place pre-Crisis where Bruce's brother Thomas Wayne Jr was locked up! So is Hurt that Thomas Wayne? Is he Daddy Thomas Wayne? Or something else?  The next lines of text seem to indicate just what he may be as Bruce states that Darkseid's fall created The Hole In Things (which is what Hurt claimed to be).  Does that make Hurt an incarnation of Darkseid or a human body in which he resides like Boss Dark Side or Turpin?  That last panel ties into "Time Masters" somewhere along the line, sending Superman, Rip Hunter, & Green Lantern Jordan on the search for Bruce Wayne through time, and also answers the question of where this last casebook was jotted down.  It was Bat's last act before he lost his memories in the fog of time, a bread crumb left in the past for Superman to find, and it is this final act that brings together "Missing Chapter" & "FC"...

The cave painting is left behind along with the recording of the final casebook entry and Bruce walks out into a world that is obviously prehistoric, given the apperance/death of Anthro that takes place in both #702 & FC #7, and walks straight into the "Return of Bruce Wayne" mini-series.  The thing I really dig is how both tales end on such similar lines..."But the fire burns forever" and "It never ends".

Man this reads completely differently when taken in this chronological order like a lot of the elements from Final Crisis make a lot more sense with the "Missing Chapter" included.  Previously it just seemed like a huge jump from the close of "RIP" and the exploding chopper to Batman doing forensics on the Orion crime scene to getting abducted by Darkseid's minions.  With the gap filled in via this reading, and the exact results of Bats taking the Omega Sanction laid out, the way in which we get to "Return of Bruce" is also more understandable.

Don't get me wrong...there are still a great deal of questions unanswered even with this take on the material, after all it wouldn't be a Morrison book if that wasn't the case.  The primary question is of course how Bruce will return to "life", and of course we still don't have a definitive answer as to the identity of Dr. Hurt, if he's even still alive, nor idea of the overall significance of Barbatos in this larger tale. 

As for non-Bruce questions: what fate will befall Gotham in the absence of a Batman? Who will step up to the mantle? Well we all know Dick Grayson & Damian assume the mantles of Batman & Robin and that is where we will begin our next chapter of this lengthy tour of Morrison's Bat-Verse!